Dear England: your oldest beers are… crazy!!

Beer isn’t my usual drink. Most of the time I have it because I’m doing a taste test, and my early reviews tended to reach the very helpful conclusion that it tasted like beer. Trying six British beers with long histories, I was surprised by how different they tasted to me.
I ended up with two favourites, Newcastle Brown Ale and Double Diamond. One seemed dark and malty, the other light and almost citrusy. I don’t have the vocabulary of someone who knows beer well, but I could tell which bottles and cans I wanted to go back to.
Watch my British beer taste test on YouTube.
Newcastle changed my mind
I started with Greene King IPA. It seemed crisp and refreshing, and I could imagine having it outside in a pub garden, although I thought I’d struggle to drink a full pint. There was a particular tang that I didn’t really want. As I tried the other beers, that reaction became more obvious.
Newcastle Brown Ale initially seemed heavier and maltier. My first thought was that I didn’t like it as much as the IPA, then another taste made me reconsider. Actually, this was better. It had a darker flavour without the tang I’d disliked in the first beer.

Later, when I compared it with Double Diamond, I thought there was something almost chocolatey about Newcastle. Are those the right words? I don’t know. Dark and malty was the best way I could explain why I liked it, and it struck me as a beer I’d rather have in winter than sitting in the sun.
I also enjoyed looking at the bottle. I’d never paid much attention to the label before, and suddenly I was noticing dates and an old award that the brewery was still pleased enough about to print. That everyday connection with history is one of my favourite things about living in the UK. A beer can be familiar to everyone else and still give me something to learn.
A lighter favourite
Double Diamond was completely new to me. I’d come across it while looking for beers for the experiment, and the account of a beer that had disappeared and then returned was exactly the sort of thing I wanted to try. I had to buy a pack of four, so I was hoping the taste would live up to my curiosity.
The packaging described it as brewed like a pale ale but drinking like a lager. At first I recognised a little of the flavour I’d disliked in the IPA, but this was much smoother. It tasted light, fruity and almost citrusy to me.
That made it a different kind of favourite from Newcastle. Double Diamond seemed suited to drinking outside in summer, while Newcastle’s darker flavour felt more like winter. I wanted to name both as winners. It’s my taste test, so I did.
Five out of six for Double Diamond, and relief that I still had three more cans. Newcastle remained the bottle I was particularly happy to return to at the end.
The middle of the pack
Fuller’s London Pride was quite nice without being especially memorable. To me, it sat somewhere between the IPA and Newcastle, without the first beer’s sharp reaction or the darker, creamier taste I liked in the second. I might still choose a cider at a pub, but I wasn’t against this.
Doom Bar was another amber ale, and I didn’t enjoy it as much as London Pride. There was a funny aftertaste. I wasn’t sure whether that belonged entirely to the beer or whether trying several drinks together was affecting my judgement, so I’m not going to pretend this was a perfectly controlled tasting. It was drinkable, just not my first choice.
Old Speckled Hen also had an aftertaste I didn’t like, along with a feeling on my tongue that put me off. London Pride was better for me, and Old Speckled Hen ended up in the lower half of my choices.
Still learning what I like
I came away thinking I didn’t like the Greene King IPA’s particular flavour, but that’s narrower than saying I dislike every IPA. I haven’t tried enough to make that claim. The useful discovery was that beers I might once have dismissed together as “beer” tasted quite different this time.
Usually, I don’t love beer enough to order it deliberately. Newcastle and Double Diamond surprised me. Trying again gave me two choices I actually liked, and two very different explanations for why.




No Comments