best crisp in britain

I want my salt and vinegar crisps to hurt a little. That probably tells you quite a lot about how I chose my favourite from a list of British crisps, and why McCoy’s salt and vinegar ended up at the top.

By my 2022 ranking, I’d spent six years living in England and trying as much British food as I could. I liked to think of myself as a professional crisp taster, whether that was remotely true or not. This was one Canadian’s opinion, based on snacks I’d already tried, rather than a fresh blind taste test of everything on the list.

Salt and vinegar has my attention

Discos were a strong contender because their salt and vinegar flavour is pretty hardcore. I was deciding whether they belonged right at the top. I also liked the Kettle balsamic vinegar ones, but McCoy’s had something extra in their favour.

I specifically remembered trying McCoy’s for the first time in a taste test about five years earlier and being so excited about them. They’d been my go-to crisps for a long time and had a special place in my heart. When I had to pick just one winner from this particular list, I went back to them.

Close view of golden ridge-cut McCoy's crisps.
Salt and malt vinegar McCoy’s, photographed in 2021. Illustrative photo by Mx. Granger, CC0 1.0. Resized and converted to WebP.

That wasn’t my only crisp with a bit of personal history. At my first job in England, I used to buy multipacks of Quavers and put a packet in my lunch pail. I wouldn’t call them the best crisp, but I have a soft spot for them, especially that really artificial cheese flavour. Delicious.

A funny shape won’t win me over

Hula Hoops were much less successful with me. Putting a crisp on your finger ought to be fun, but for some reason their shape just didn’t do it for me. I couldn’t give you a particularly good explanation. I simply didn’t like it.

I felt similarly unenthusiastic about Pom-Bears. A crisp doesn’t need to have an interesting shape for me to enjoy it, and I didn’t really care about these. Chipsticks weren’t horrible, but they weren’t incredible either; French Fries seemed quite similar to them in my opinion. I was much more interested in something tasting good than in it looking entertaining.

There were plenty of flavours I liked without wanting to crown them. Sweet chilli Sensations were divine, and sour cream Pringles were really good too. Cheese and onion could sit comfortably in the middle. I wasn’t trying to make every crisp either my absolute favourite or something I hated.

Disgusting, delicious and sometimes both

Meat-flavoured crisps are where things often go wrong for me. They never seem to taste like meat; they just taste weird. Frazzles got an immediate no, and by the end I was happy to name the bacon Frazzles my least favourite of this lot.

But my opinions weren’t entirely consistent. I began complaining that barbecue rib was the worst Walkers flavour to choose, then immediately admitted that it actually wasn’t too bad.

Scampi Fries were delicious, which I slightly hated myself for admitting. There was something about them, and they were so salty that they seemed made for eating in a pub. Pickled onion Monster Munch had a similar effect. I decided to judge that flavour even though I couldn’t clearly identify the tiny packet on the ranking list, and found it a little disgusting but pretty good.

Nik Naks brought back another early taste-test memory. Lemon ‘n’ Scampi had been one of the first convenience-store snacks I tried on my channel, and I remembered them fondly. Nice ‘n’ Spicy wasn’t my favourite Nik Naks flavour, although it still deserved a reasonable place in the ranking.

Onion rings raised a separate question. I found them kind of disgusting but quite moreish, and those aren’t necessarily the same thing as good. I’ve certainly tried snacks I wanted to keep eating even when I didn’t particularly like them. An empty packet wouldn’t automatically prove I’d found my winner.

I also had to admit that I’d never been offered a crisp and said no. Whether I enjoyed it or moderately disliked it was another matter. So yes, Frazzles came last and McCoy’s salt and vinegar won, but even a fairly opinionated crisp ranking wasn’t going to stop me eating the others.

Watch my original video about my British crisp ranking.