irish crisps

After six years living in England and trying British snacks, I finally got to try some Irish ones. A viewer called Aaron sent a selection to my PO box, which was especially exciting because I hadn’t been able to find Tayto down in Kent. I didn’t know every packet in the pile.

Salt and vinegar set the standard

The Tayto salt and vinegar crisps were a very good start. They were regular crisps, not super-thick or kettle-cooked, but the flavour was strong. I loved that proper salt-and-vinegar taste. Five and a half out of six Mr. Tayto men. Salt and vinegar could disappoint me if there wasn’t enough flavour, and these certainly didn’t have that problem.

Alanna showing the blue Tayto Salt and Vinegar crisp packet
The classic Tayto salt and vinegar crisps I chose as my favourite. Frame from my original video.

The salt and vinegar Spirals were delicious too. I love it when companies make spirals, although I couldn’t explain why, and these had plenty of the flavour I wanted. I gave them seven out of eight potato spirals. Still, I thought I liked the classic crisp a little more. I planned to eat the rest of the Spirals when the camera was off, so it wasn’t exactly a harsh rejection.

The onion rings sent me back to a very specific Canadian reference. Their flavour reminded me of an original Mr. Noodles seasoning packet, and that was the best way I could describe it. They tasted extremely artificial, but also tasty. Sometimes that artificial flavour is exactly what you want. Three out of six Mr. Noodles.

A good shape couldn’t rescue every flavour

The oven-baked Texan Grill snacks looked like little cups, and I liked both their shape and their crunch. I am a crunch person. The flavour, unfortunately, wasn’t good to me. Meat-flavoured junk food often disappointed me, and this was another example. As a whole snack, taking both texture and flavour into account, they got one out of four Texan flags. I could imagine liking that shape in another flavour, but not this one.

Bikers looked like bicycle wheels. The front of the packet had made me think they might be like pretzels, but they were actually much more puffed. Their flavour started off very sweet to me, then finished with a generic spiciness, which was an odd combination. Two out of nine bicycles. I didn’t really care for the puffed texture either. Again, I wanted crunch.

The French onion version of the oven-baked snacks was a much better discovery. I’d already liked the texture of the Texan Grill ones, and this flavour was much more my style. Delicious, and a solid seven out of eight onions. If they’d been a classic crisp, I thought they’d have earned a perfect score, but the slightly puffed texture held them just below that. I was still going to eat the rest.

The familiar crisp had another advantage

Tayto’s prawn cocktail crisps were different from another brand I’d tried in an earlier tasting. Those other ones had smelled fishy, which had put me off. These didn’t, and their taste was almost ketchupy. At first I liked them more, but then I changed my mind about my enthusiasm. Eight out of eleven shrimps. Not fishy was nice, but they weren’t that great either.

The smoky bacon crisps were much less ambiguous. They were really smoky, with an artificial meat flavour that wasn’t for me at all. I went back for another taste, because science, and the result didn’t improve. Three out of nine strips of plastic bacon. These flavours weren’t going to beat salt and vinegar for me.

Cheese and onion ended the crisp tasting on a better note. I was quite partial to that flavour, even though it wasn’t my go-to, and these were good. The classic potato crisp shape was delicious. I didn’t need bicycle wheels or puffed things to enjoy it. Seven out of eight and a half cheesy onions.

Orange pop belonged with the winner

There was a drink in Aaron’s selection too: Club Orange with real bits. I loved seeing “juicy bits” on packaging here, compared with the word “pulp” that I was used to in North America. The orange pop was delicious, although that might partly have been because it had been about six years since I’d had any. It reminded me of being nine at someone’s birthday party, with pizza and orange pop. Eight out of eight juicy bits.

My winners were the classic Tayto salt and vinegar crisps and the Club Orange. Give me those two and I was set for the rest of the day. The more unusual shapes had been interesting to try, but the regular crisp with plenty of flavour was the one I wanted most.

Watch my Irish crisp and snack taste test.