Is Christmas better in Canada or the UK?

My first Christmas in the UK was in 2015, about a month after I arrived. I was at the house of people I didn’t know very well, and they gave me a huge helping of Christmas pudding. I didn’t feel I could tell them I hated it, so I ate as much as I could and hated every minute. That was a difficult introduction to a Christmas tradition.

By my eighth Christmas here, England felt like a second home and I’d started making my own traditions. There were things I’d kept from my family Christmas in Canada and British things I’d added, including Yorkshire puddings. Christmas pudding still wasn’t one of them. I’d tried plenty of versions by then, and none had changed my mind.

Two kinds of potatoes, please

I can only compare the Christmases I’ve known. Canadian friends have different traditions from my family, so this isn’t a complete description of either country. Our Christmas dinner usually meant turkey, mashed potatoes, rolls, gravy, vegetables and stuffing, with pie for dessert. My favourite cranberry sauce was the gelatinous canned kind. I loved that stuff.

The British Christmas plate I described had a lot in common with that meal, but roast potatoes were a welcome addition. If I could have mashed potatoes and roast potatoes together, I would. Parsnips were another matter. They were evil carrots as far as I was concerned, while Yorkshire puddings were lovely enough that I’d started making them part of Christmas myself.

Pigs in blankets gave me another good comparison. The ones I’d known in Canada were sausages wrapped in pastry, while the British version I was talking about had bacon wrapped around the sausage. I liked both. Pastry and meat was hard to argue with, and the British version gave you double meat. I hadn’t had the pastry ones for a long time and missed them.

Small sausages wrapped in golden baked dough on a baking tray.
Illustrative North American-style sausages wrapped in baked dough, not my Christmas dinner. Pigs in blanket – Hillshire Farm Lit’l Smokies by William F. Yurasko, CC BY 2.0. No changes.

The Christmas morning I grew up with

In my family, we got up at a reasonable time on Christmas morning. Not five in the morning. I like my sleep. We started with stockings, which might have chocolates, socks or nail polish inside, and then had breakfast. Eggs, bacon, toast, fruit and orange juice were the sort of things on the table.

We had a real fireplace, but we also put the fireplace channel on the television. I liked trying to catch the moment when somebody poked the fire on screen. Then we opened presents one at a time, taking turns around the family, rather than everybody tearing into everything at once. I loved handing out the presents, even though opening them that way could take quite a while.

Afterwards, it was time to look at what we’d got, put batteries in toys or try on new socks. Dinner came around five or six. That was very different from the British Christmas dinners I’d known around two in the afternoon. I didn’t really want a huge meal that early, especially when it left me feeling awful and ready to collapse on the couch.

There would be chocolates afterwards, too, including Quality Street, which hadn’t been one of my family’s Christmas traditions in Canada. By about eight in the evening, there were leftovers. The food itself wasn’t the only difference for me. The time you ate it changed the shape of the day.

An early Christmas with my mum

Christmas abroad can be tough, even when the place you live has started to feel like home. My mum had visited the previous year, and when I made this video she was planning to come again in early December. We’d have a little Christmas of our own and give each other presents in person before she went back to Canada for the actual day.

I wanted to show her my ordinary life here. Restaurants I liked, markets, a pub, and the places I enjoyed spending time mattered more to me than making every outing a tourist attraction. We’d had snow and train strikes during her previous visit, which had interrupted some of our plans. This time I hoped we’d get to do more Christmas things together.

She’d be back with my family and grandma for Christmas, while I’d join in by FaceTime for the presents. Having that early celebration together had worked well the year before. I was looking forward to doing it again, with a little Canadian family Christmas here in England before the two countries had their Christmas Day apart.

Watch my Canadian and British Christmas comparison.