Aldi taste test

I went to Aldi to buy things for a blind taste test and bought far too much. In my 2023 experiment, I wanted to know whether I could tell familiar branded foods from Aldi’s versions when I couldn’t see them. I had a blindfold, a receipt and more things to eat than was sensible.

The packaging was part of what made me laugh before I started. So many of the Aldi products had colours and shapes very close to the products I recognised, with just enough changed. Looking at them, the resemblance seemed obvious. Tasting them without seeing the wrappers was a different problem.

The Seal bar fooled me immediately

I started with Penguin bars and Aldi’s Seal bars. They felt exactly the same to me. The first one was very chocolatey, with plenty of chocolate inside, and I preferred it to the second, which tasted more caramelised and biscuity. I decided the first must be the Penguin.

It was the Seal bar. I was shocked, both because I’d guessed wrong and because I hadn’t liked the Penguin as much. I thought I would be able to tell that pair apart, but the Aldi bar had been the one I wanted to eat.

The pickle comparison went better. I’m not much of a pickle person, but I tried Branston Original Pickle against Bramwells Sweet Pickle. One tasted more vinegary and tangy, while the other seemed sweeter. Because Aldi’s jar said Sweet Pickle, I used that as my clue, and I got it right. If I had to choose, I preferred the tangier original.

I recognised the things I knew well

My everyday favourite cheese at the time was the twelve-month Davidstow Cornwall cheddar. I put it against Aldi’s British mature cheese, strength four. I was very confident the first bite wasn’t my usual cheese, and the second was. Thankfully, I was right, because being that sure and still losing would have been embarrassing.

I wasn’t calling Aldi’s cheese bad. I thought it was a good cheese, just not quite the same as the one I loved. The difference was easy for me to recognise in that pairing.

Cadbury Fingers gave me another correct answer. I loved them and thought the chocolate might be the thing I recognised. The two versions were very close, but my gut reaction was that the second tasted like Cadbury chocolate. I guessed correctly and felt vindicated after the earlier failures, joking that surely this qualified me for British citizenship.

The cheesy tortilla-chip comparison was much less subtle. I really disliked the first one, both the chip and its coating, and was certain it was Aldi’s version. The second was the Dorito I wanted. I got that right too, and said I would pay for the original. That was one pair where the cheaper version didn’t taste right to me.

Cola and chocolate made guessing difficult

I usually drank Coke Zero, so I hadn’t had original Coke in a long time. Against Aldi’s Vive Cola, I couldn’t find much to go on. They tasted and smelled so similar that I tried using a tiny difference in flavour to choose. I got them the wrong way round. Maybe a regular original-Coke drinker would have found it easier, but I hadn’t.

Aldi sold both Snickers and its Racer bar, so I bought the two together. In bite-sized pieces, they seemed almost identical to me. I couldn’t pick out a single clear taste difference and made a complete guess. It happened to be right, but I didn’t want to count that as a proper win. Once I could see them, the Snickers bar was a little longer and denser.

The noodles ended with another surprise

For the final pair, I tried chicken-and-mushroom Pot Noodle against Bramwells Snack Noodles in the same flavour. We prepared them in the same way, then my assistant mixed them up before I tasted them.

The two chicken-and-mushroom noodle pots held side by side.
The chicken-and-mushroom noodle pots I compared in my 2023 blind taste test.

I thought they tasted almost the same. For some reason, I slightly preferred one and called it the real Pot Noodle. That was another wrong answer: I’d preferred Aldi’s. I couldn’t explain exactly why, and for me the taste difference was almost impossible to identify. By then I was dripping noodles, I’d lost some on the floor and my stomach hurt. I was surprised by the results, and I still had two pots to eat.

Watch the original Taste testing hilarious ALDI DUPES vs Original Brands video.